First Liberty Institute recently sent a letter to St. Philip’s College in San Antonio, Texas, telling community college officials it was illegal and improper to terminate Dr. Johnson Varkey, a former adjunct professor who taught at the institution for nearly 20 years, CBN news reports.
Calling Varkey’s views on science and gender “widely accepted biology,” Keisha Russell, counsel for First Liberty Institute, asked St. Philip’s College to reinstate the educator.
“The college violated Dr. Varkey’s constitutional and statutory rights when it fired him, and it must reinstate him immediately,” the June 20 letter proclaimed.
According to source, the college informed him of an ethics complaint in January and terminated him just weeks later, purportedly without allowing him to learn the precise reason for his firing.
Furthermore, Varkey said he had no opportunity to offer any defense.
“On the 12th of January, I received an email from the vice president of the department of the school that they are doing an ethics violation investigation on me,” he said. “So, I responded to his email and asked him, ‘What are the complaints?’”
Varkey said he was told he would hear from human resources but alleges no one contacted him until Jan. 27, when he was given a termination letter.
The professor, who taught more than 1,500 students about human biology since taking the position in 2003, was left to postulate about the root cause of his firing. In November, he told a class sex is determined by chromosomes X and Y, a biological fact.
A few students walked out of the classroom, leading him to ponder whether this was the catalyst of the complaints at the center of his termination.
Varkey’s termination letter reportedly referenced grievances filed against him for “religious preaching, discriminatory comments about homosexuals and transgender individuals, anti-abortion rhetoric, and misogynistic banter.”
But Varkey said he was “surprised and shocked” by his dismissal. He’s been teaching the same realities about the human reproductive system for two decades, and this is reportedly the first time he has experienced a negative reaction.
“I’ve been teaching for that school for the last 20 years and without any complaints,” he said. “So, I was shocked to see that letter.”
Russell said she and First Liberty has decided to take the case for various reasons, but mainly found it compelling Varkey had been teaching for so long without incident. Beyond that, she said there is an understanding the case “probably has a lot to do with the new cultural trends on these issues.”
“When I saw the termination letter, and I see that the university is accusing him of religious preaching … I think that what they don’t understand is, even if he was, they still can’t fire him for saying something that he believes to be true,” she said. “One of the things he said was that life begins at conception.”
While some might view this as a religious belief, she said it’s “scientific,” and the professor was speaking from a baseline of “ethical integrity” and “academic integrity.”
“It’s also protected speech under the First Amendment, so all the way around the university is wrong here,” Russell said. “We just think it’s a shame that they would fire one of their long-term professors for teaching what he’s always taught.”
The letter to St. Philip’s College alleges the school “violated the Free Speech Clause and Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act, among multiple other statutory provisions.”
Russell said Varkey wants to be reinstated to his position and wants his “record cleared.”
“He didn’t do anything wrong,” she said.
A request for comment from the college has not yet been returned.